Batman Cataclysm Review | Graphic Novel Talk

October 10, 2017 No comments exist

Batman Cataclysm Review By Deffinition as part of my Batman Chronological Graphic Novel Read Through

Batman Cataclysm Review By Deffinition – Contains Spoilers

Batman Cataclysm takes place during the mid point of Chuck Dixon‘s legendary Batman run. After surviving the Apocalypse virus that ravaged Gotham, the heroes finally feel like they’re making headway in the war on crime.

However, that can easily be stopped when Mother Nature gets involved.

I’ve never read Cataclysm before but I’m a huge fan of Dixon’s work and the ‘real world’ problems that he often pits the Dark Knight against. It’s going to be interesting if he can deliver on the work that has preceded this book.

So, with that out the way, let’s dive in to Batman Cataclysm.

‘I took down the bat’

The book opens in an exceptionally unique and creative way. One that I’ve not seen thus far in my Batman Chronological Canon Read Through. We see a prisoner lying to inmates about his run in with the Batman. Side by side we view his telling of the events vs the reality. In one stroke Dixon expertly gives insight into the criminal minds in Gotham, whilst elevating the myth of The Batman. It really opens the book with a human touch and throughout the introduction we are treated to a personal side of Gotham through taking the perspective of it’s citizens.

It’s this citizen’s perspective that carries on thematically throughout the graphic novel. This adds weight to the story and makes it easier to related to with the impending doom that is to follow.

The Earthquake

The Earthquake devastates Gotham in a breathtaking way. Ripping the streets, Wayne Manor and even the Batcave apart . We see the majority of the Bat family in peril and it is a unique situation to pit our characters in.

Dixon has once again depicted a real world scenario and puts to page how the fantastical would deal with it. This mesh of reality and the absurd is something that always elevated his books previously and here it is no different.

Earthquake destroys gotham

Mother Nature

It’s common knowledge how Batman would deal with super villains but tragedies of this monumental scale are rarely touched upon in the comic book genre. Metaphorically we are able to see how the Bat family act as emergency services and it never really struck me till now that the heroes of Gotham are the police, fire and medical department in one.

Nothing is as cruel as Mother Nature and through this book we are able to view first hand the event and aftermath from both citizen and superhero perspective alike.

Bedlam at Blackgate

Gotham is rife with criminals and they too are unable to escape the effects of the quake. However, that isn’t necessarily a bad thing from their perspective. After being freed from their cages due to the seismic force tearing through Blackgate island it’s up to Batman to go in and stop the criminals reaching mainland Gotham.

We view the breakout through the eyes of a wrongly convicted Death Row inmate. Truly getting a glimpse at the humanity and good will that is often brought forth from such tragedies. It’s an epic arc for such a no name character. Dixon does well to get you invested in this stranger and his eventual outcome will have you in disbelief. I really recommend picking up the book for this arc alone as it’s one of the best standalone isues in the canon read through thus far.

Wicked One Shots

During the mid section of the book we get some absolutely brilliant one shots. Mixing in opinions and perspectives from the likes of Ra’s Al Ghul and Two Face to Robin and Nightwing we are granted with a full spectrum of survival tales. One of the most harrowing centres around a man screaming for help, eventually rescuers descend on his location. He believes himself to be saved but when they pick up a baby from the rubble and leave, missing the man, he’s hit with the crushing realisation that they did not hear him under all the rubble. He is truly doomed.

It packs a real punch!

It’s aspects like this that really laid a dramatic foundation for the main story to catapult off of. This was no longer a Batman story, it was a Gotham story. One that is easy to translate to real life and the book should be regarded highly because of this.

Contrasting Contagion we are given more of a full picture of the pleas of the quake survivors and due to this are able to connect with the strange characters in a deeper way than we can most main stay heroes and villains.

Quakemaster identity In Batman Cataclysm

The QuakeMaster

Holding the city to ransom The mysterious QuakeMaster claims to have been the force that cause the devastation upon Gotham. Initially I was put off by this, preferring that the quake was just a random event, however as the book goes on you learn it was just that. The QuakeMaster, when unmasked, is shown to be another of Batman’s rogues attempting to get rich quick.

I’m glad that the creative team decided to go with this as it could have been make or break for me. Instead they are able to have their cake and eat it. Allowing Batman to deal with the forces of nature whilst also providing a more run of the Mill comic book tale to whet the appetite of action seeking fans.

It’s this balance that allows the story to finish with a well developed Climax that segways beautifully into the next arc: Aftershock.

The Verdict

Batman Cataclysm rights the wrongs of Contagion, providing a grounded, insightful story to the way that the mystical comic book superhero would handle a real world event. Being shown primarily from the perspective of regular Gothamites allows us to connect with the tragedy in a way like never before.

It’s a firsthand view of how devastating an event like this could be and this grounded aesthetic adds to the books authenticity.

I had a brilliant time with Cataclysm and it perfectly invests you in the major arc that is to come: No Man’s Land.

That’s why Cataclysm gets an…


If you’ve been following my reviews then you know that i’m ranking the books as I read them in what all the fans of me lovingly call ‘Rank As I Read’ or ‘Rank As You Read’…I don’t know, I can’t remember, you do though as you’re a proper fan.

So here is the leaderboard so far.

  1. Batman The Cult
  2. The Dark Knight Returns
  3. Batman The Long Halloween
  4. The Killing Joke
  5. Batman: Arkham Asylum A Serious House On Serious Earth
  6. Batman And The Monster Men
  7. The Flash: Flaspoint
  8. Justice League Origin Review
  9. All Star Batman Ends Of The Earth
  10. Batman The Last Arkham
  11. Batman Dark Victory
  12. Batman: The Man Who Laughs
  13. JLA Rock Of Ages
  14. Justice League VS Suicide Squad
  15. Batman Vengeance Of Bane
  16. Batman Knightsend
  17. Trinity
  18. Batman Bride Of The Demon
  19. Batman: Year One
  20. Batman: Venom
  21. All Star Batman: My Own Worst Enemy
  22. Batman Birth Of The Demon
  23. JLA New World Order Review (Vol 1)
  24. Batman Legacy Volume 1 Review
  25. Batman Cataclysm
  26. DC Rebirth 
  27. Batman A Death In The Family
  28. Batman: Night Cries
  29. Batman: Gothic
  30. Batman Snow
  31. Batman Knightfall
  32. Justice League Throne Of Atlantis
  33. Justice League The Villain’s Journey
  34. Batman/The Flash: The Button Review
  35. Batman: I Am Gotham
  36. Batman: Fears
  37. Batman: Prey
  38. Robin Year One
  39. Batman And The Mad Monk
  40. Batman: Son Of The Demon
  41. Batman Blind Justice
  42. Batman Ego
  43. Batman: Shaman
  44. Crisis On Infinite Earths
  45. Batman: Contagion
  46. Batman: Terror
  47. Batman A Lonely Place Of Dying
  48. JLA Secret Files #1
  49. Batman Sword Of Azrael
  50. Batman The Black Spider
  51. Batman: Faces
  52. Batgirl: Year One
  53. Batman Prodigal
  54. Justice League: The Grid
  55. The Death Of Superman
  56. JLA Imaginary Stories
  57. Catwoman: When In Rome
  58. Batman: Madness
  59. Batman: Ghosts
  60. Batman Knightsquest
  61. JLA Woman Of Tomorrow
  62. Batman Rebirth #1
  63. Batman Doug Moench and Kelley Jones Volume 1
  64. Batman: Strange Apparitions
  65. Batman Second Chances
  66. Earth 2 The Gathering
  67. JLA Fire In The Sky
  68. The Dark Knight Strikes Again
  69. Batman The Ugly American

Thank You!

Thanks so much for checking out my article. If you liked it please subscribe to my Patreon by clicking here! Buying graphic novels, cinema tickets and games isn't cheap so every penny towards it helps. If you can pledge an amount that you wouldn't miss if you dropped it in the street it would make a big difference to me and my website. Please donate whatever you can. Thank you, Paul.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *